Carmine's Pizzeria- Authentic New York Style Pizzas

Carmine's Pizzeria is a family-run New York-style pizzeria on Northmount Dr NW, and the whole menu is halal. The Mediterranean and the Donair Pie are the pizzas regulars come back for. The O.G. and the Hawaiian are also worth trying, and the pastas, poutine and garlic bread are there if you want more than pizza. Feeding a crowd It suits a family night out. For a party, order ahead: a stack of large pizzas can be ready in about 25 minutes. Good to know There are vegetarian options on the menu, so a mixed group can all find something to eat.

Carmine's Pizzeria- Authentic New York Style Pizzas

Carmine's Pizzeria is a family-run New York-style pizzeria on Northmount Dr NW, and the whole menu is halal. The Mediterranean and the Donair Pie are the pizzas regulars come back for. The O.G. and the Hawaiian are also worth trying, and the pastas, poutine and garlic bread are there if you want more than pizza. Feeding a crowd It suits a family night out. For a party, order ahead: a stack of large pizzas can be ready in about 25 minutes. Good to know There are vegetarian options on the menu, so a mixed group can all find something to eat.

Carmine's Pizzeria- Authentic New York Style Pizzas
Submit a Place
Know a halal spot we're missing? Tell us about it.

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Report this listing
Let us know what's wrong with this listing.

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Articles
Halal Calgary
Halal food and places to pray, all on one map
↺ Reset map view
Carmine's Pizzeria- Authentic New York Style Pizzas
Uber Eats DoorDash SkipTheDishes
Carmine's Pizzeria- Authentic New York Style Pizzas
★ 4.5 (335 ratings) · $10–20
390 Northmount Dr NW, Calgary, AB T2K 3H5, Canada · (403) 457-8885
Pizza Italian European Fast Food Comfort Food
Website
Dine-in Takeout Delivery

Reviews of Carmine's Pizzeria- Authentic New York Style Pizzas

from Google
4.5 335 Ratings

What an amazing pizza place! We stopped here while visiting Calgary, and it was one of the best meals of our trip. The pizza was fresh, flavorful, perfectly cooked, and made with high-quality ingredients. Every bite was delicious! The staff were just as impressive—friendly, welcoming, attentive, and genuinely made us feel like valued guests. The service was fast, and everyone had a smile on their face, which made the experience even better. If you’re in Calgary and looking for great pizza with outstanding customer service, this place is definitely worth a visit. We will absolutely come back the next time we’re in town. Highly recommend!

Ziza T 2 months ago Read on Google

Carmine’s in an excellent Pizzeria! The staff are very friendly, and they have a great variety of pizzas to try. They serve slices during school hours and the full pizzas do not take that long if you order ahead (our order only took 25 minutes). We ordered several large pizzas for a family get together and they were a hit with everyone! The pizzas were hot and fresh, the sauce was delicious, and the dough was perfect. While the pizzas are were a bit on the pricy side, they were well worth it. All my family also agreed that the pizza is even better after the new owners took over. Well worth the stop!

Colby 10 months ago Read on Google

I used to love this place so much that I’d recommend it to anyone and everyone I knew. I would always say it was “the closest thing you can get to New York–style pizza in Calgary.” But things have changed drastically. What used to be a reliable, delicious, and even visually appealing pizza has turned into something unrecognizable. The crust is overworked and chewy in all the wrong ways, the toppings sit in a layer of grease, and the flavour that used to set them apart is just… gone. The pasta has become bland and lifeless, and the meatballs (which were once a standout) now taste unmistakably store-bought. It’s genuinely frustrating to watch a place that used to take so much pride in its food decline this sharply. I’m not trying to be dramatic, but the quality drop is impossible to ignore, and it deserves to be acknowledged. I’m incredibly disappointed to see one of my favourite spots fall this far.

Nathan B 10 months ago Read on Google

To truly understand how good Carmine's pizza is, you need to know this: my wife hates pizza — but she loves Carmine's. That alone says everything. As a self-proclaimed pizza fanatic who has tried pizza from all over, along with my equally enthusiastic kids, I can confidently say Carmine's is easily one of the best in Calgary and among the best I've ever had. Every pizza is made with exceptional care, and each one looks exactly like the pictures in the brochure. I've worked my way through much of the menu, and some personal favourites include the O.G., the Daily Slice, and the Hawaiian. But honestly, I've never once been disappointed by anything I've ordered. Beyond the pizza, their pastas and poutine are both excellent, and their garlic bread is absolutely amazing. What really sets Carmine's apart, though, is the family behind it. They are truly wonderful people who run a top-notch operation. Every visit, they make you feel genuinely welcome and go above and beyond to deliver great service. I can't recommend Carmine's Pizza highly enough. Do yourself a favour and give them a try.

Travis Stevens 6 months ago Read on Google

I’m in complete awe!! I was driving around the city looking for authentic European pizza and it seemed almost impossible; until I found this pizzeria.. I called in and the lady was so friendly with great customer service; the owner welcomed me warmly and the son was so nice to me I was confident that the pizza would be great. the PIZZA WAS AMAZING…. we ordered the Mediterranean pizza and it was one of the best pizzas I had in the city… I will continue coming here. I am done with the other pizza spots because this is my new spot!! Thank You!!!!!

Nikki Flex 9 months ago Read on Google

This is hands down the best spot for Italian food. The service was incredible and the quality of the food was out of the world. I recommend this spot to my friends and they all say it's a gem of Calgary. My go-to is the Donair Pie, but you can't go wrong with anything you order here.

Atin Sulaiman a month ago Read on Google

About Carmine's Pizzeria- Authentic New York Style Pizzas

Carmine's Pizzeria is a family-run New York-style pizzeria on Northmount Dr NW, and the whole menu is halal.

The Mediterranean and the Donair Pie are the pizzas regulars come back for. The O.G. and the Hawaiian are also worth trying, and the pastas, poutine and garlic bread are there if you want more than pizza.

Feeding a crowd

It suits a family night out. For a party, order ahead: a stack of large pizzas can be ready in about 25 minutes.

Good to know

There are vegetarian options on the menu, so a mixed group can all find something to eat.

Open Google Maps